Can the Study of Politics Be Scientific or Not - 606 Words

PL 115 ASSIGNMENT Q. 2 The aim of this essay is to discuss â€Å"Can the study of politics be scientific or not?† and I will give reasons for my arguments. It will be divided into three parts: the first part is the introduction, the second part discusses politics and science then the last part concludes the essay. Keywords: Politics and Scientific DEFINITIONS Politics: There are various definitions of politics. i. Politics is the art of managing conflicts. Conflicts occur at different levels for example between two or more people, between communities and between countries that is when people compete for different positions and when we go to vote. ii. Politics can be understood as power and influence; that is it involves power,†¦show more content†¦Refuting the Scientific character of Political Science Maitland: an eminent English writer- observes â€Å"when I see asset of examination questions headed by the words Political Science I regret the question but the title† F.W Maitland: collected paper volume 11. Buckle another famous author also observes that â€Å"In the present state of knowledge, politics so far from being a Science is the most backward of all the arts.† (Buckle: History of Civilization Vol. 1 pg. 361). While analysis this statement of buckle the following comment of Dr. Garner on this statement is wo rth noting to his book â€Å"Political Science and Government,† Dr. Garner writes, â€Å"Buckle, however, did not deny a possibility of a political Science what he lamented was that so little attention had been given to the study of the state that as a systematic branch of knowledge it was to crude and undeveloped to be considered a Science.† Dr. Garner: â€Å"Political Science and Government,† pg. 13. Of the same opinion is J.S mill who wrote in 1843, â€Å"it is accordingly but of yesterday that a concept of political Science has existed anywhere but in the mind of, here and there, an isolated thinker, generally very ill-prepared of the realization.† J. S Mill: â€Å"System of logic,† pg. 547. The German scholars have gone to the extent of adopting analytical methods in order to give this subject theShow MoreRelatedWith Respect To The Concerning Question, There Has Been1473 Words   |  6 Pagesthe Study of Politics is a science. Aristotle descr ibed politics as the â€Å"master science†; Hobbs, Pollock, Bryce and many others have long considered Politics to be a scientific study. Inversely, Mosca, Comte and Maitland, among others, question its eligibility. †¨According to the Oxford Dictionaries, Science can be described as, â€Å"A systematically organised body of knowledge on a particular subject† where Science is split into two key types: natural and social. It can be claimed that Politics is aRead MoreIs Politics A Science?1058 Words   |  5 PagesIs politics a science in the first place? Numerous scholars believe politics is too normative to be considered a â€Å"Science† and that the generalizations made in science cannot be implemented in politics, furthermore, some say it is more of an art than science. Aristotle described politics as the â€Å"Master Science† as it relates to all other disciplines such as economy and philosophy. Personally I had my doubts in the beginning of the c ourse of how much science can be in politics and if it is truly aRead MoreIs the Study of Politics Best Considered a Science or an Art?1733 Words   |  7 PagesIs the study of politics best considered a science or an art? Since its conception as a formal academic discipline, Politics has existed on the fault line between two great fields of enquiry, the sciences and the arts. During the mid 20th century, with the rise of the behavioural movement, a general trend towards the â€Å"scientification† of the study of politics could be observed. The origins of this movement can be traced back to the logical positivism of the Vienna Circle and the writings of AugusteRead MoreWeberian Bureaucracy Essay1417 Words   |  6 Pagesbureaucracy. Weber’s studies developed more into the bureaucratic aspect, focusing on politics and administration. In his writing Politics as a Vocation Weber defined the state as being an â€Å"entity that possesses a monopoly on the legitimate use of physical force† and politics is the sharing of state powers between various groups and the political leaders that wield that power. Weber even wrote that â€Å" Bureaucratic administration means fundamental dominat ion through knowledge† As his studies of bureaucracyRead MoreFour Main Theorists Of The Classical Approach To Public Administration738 Words   |  3 Pageswhich was the Bureaucratic, Scientific, Administrative, and Managerial approach. Each area represented the four main theorists that the classical approach was associated with. Max Webers bureaucratic approach focused on the rational-legal model which viewed bureaucracy from a rational view and argued that bureaucracy is the most efficient and rational way in which one can organize the human activity and that hierarchies are necessary to maintain order. The scientific approach by Taylor accordingRead MoreEssay on Sociology and Social Sciences1144 Words   |  5 Pagesthe people in a modern society. Answer: 1.Psychology (How humans think influences most, if not all of the social sciences.)   2.Sociology (This helps figure out how society thinks. If you understand how society thinks, you can improve it.)   3.Political Science (Politics runs every country.)   4.History (This helps everybody now which ideas and actions were successful, and which ones were mistakes.)   5.Economics (Money also runs every country,obviously.)   6.Anthropology ( Everybody wants toRead MoreFeminist Perspectives On Gender And Science, Why Engage Genomics? Essay1581 Words   |  7 Pagesgenomics in current discussions of gender and sex is what makes the domain of genomics a point of feminist concern. Historically, science tends to support popular views of sex and gender due to pressures on scientists to produce empirical data that can be interpreted to support or â€Å"prove† current societal views as correct. Feminists, philosophers and other critical thinkers cannot afford to leave genetics to the geneticists; governments, corporations and other bodies of power will not simply acquiesceRead MoreProblems Of The And Boundary Work1392 Words   |  6 PagesBoundary Work One of the fundamental areas of study concerning professionals, including lawyers and scientists, is that of professional boundaries (Lamont Molnar). Where are the bounds of the profession? Who is included and who is excluded from the profession? One of the driving questions for scholars of science has been the demarcation problem, that is determining what is and is not included in science (Gieryn 1983). Historically, the social studies of science has divided between internal and externalRead Moreon killing a tree Essay1240 Words   |  5 Pagesemphasizes on scientific, objective and value free study of political phenomenon. This approach stresses upon the use of empirical as well as scientific methods of study political behavior. This approach shifts its emphasis from the study of the state and government to the day-today problems, activities and behaviour of individuals and groups. Behavioural approach has portraits individuals as center of attention and examines their behaviour, actions and tries to comprehend them through a scientific outlookRead MoreComparative Politics Essay1392 Words   |  6 Pagesknow no country.† – Seymour Martin Lipset. The scholar Guy Swanson once said, â€Å"Thinking without comparison is unthinkable. And, in the absence of comparison, so is all scientific thought and scientific research.† (cited in Ragin, 1992). As such, comparison is necessary for the development of political science. The ‘art of comparing’ can be seen as what experimentation is to most sciences – the principal and most effective way to test theory. (Peters, 1998) This essay seeks to describe the different